Uh... It might just be me having a dumb moment, but, isn't the network effect that "one person draws in many others to their network, which inspires others to join said network"?
People don't join nostr because they think it is a community of "just" bitcoiners.
They do join BlueSky because some of their favorite creators go there too.
They start creating on BlueSky because it is presented to them as a better alternative than Twitter (I hear many artists went to BS because they felt more welcome there)
Communities in Nostr never (really) worked out because people spent forever arguing on how to name them or how to make them accessible. Reddit has r/name, 4chan also had a prefix system...so nostr has n/naddrkajröoilgjsdröofjsdöflkgjhsökldjg - not exactly the easiest to throw a friend while sitting in a bus and chatting :p (it should've just been nip-05 reuse, imho; n/name.tld -> name.tld/.well-known/nostr-community.json -> npub + metadata imho).
Private communities SHOULD stay either on their own relay (making sure that people's private space totally stays private) whilst public ones should be spread as far and wide as possible but advertised with several "core relays".
Again, I could be misunderstanding you in this one, apologies if I did. ^^' But I think it's less of a problem in relay distribution, but more of a... "marketing problem". Making people interested, feel welcome and give them a good reason to join. For example: "You should use Nostr communities because Patreon and Twitch take a cut off of your payment, but we do not." ... however, payments on nostr are crypto, and not that many folks are into crypto, especially creators who just wanna create and have an easy out. So the client, for this kinda system, would have to abstract this away to high oblivion and possibly even offer a custodial service for the ease of use. o.o; I.e., hold an API token to a BitRefill account, which the creator can link, and then use to both receive lightning but also "cash out".
Login to reply
Replies (1)
We just don’t have a spec for open communities that is distributed and not top down opinionated on moderation. I’m looking at it through a lens of topics and relays as places where these topics are discussed and moderated.
These topics are universal (like #bitcoin) but the communities around these topics are distributed through time and space. So it’s all connected and global, but local when you want it to be.
I should be able to filter on the sci.physics.quantum topic across the set of all university relays on earth, or the fringe cross section online, or maybe a geographical area.
Communities naturally form around topics, so i find them an interesting connection point that you can build a distributed protocol on top of.