You would think. But the US has adopted a new policy by which they are not returning people to their country of citizenship.
Non-Mexicans have been deported to Mexico. A mother of four children was deported with two of her kids, the two others remained in the US. She is not from Mexico. She is a foreigner with nothing, no job, and two kinds. Had they been sent back home, they would have had their family to help them out.
Usually, the process for deportation requires the government to prove the criteria for deportation are met, allows for the defendant to have representation, and requires for a judge to decide on the merit of the case if the defendant contests the deportation. But the US government doesn't follow those rules.
To make things worst, in the case of El Salvador, the US government is contracting the El Salvadorian government to detain people they have deported. In other words they are paying to have people detained in a foreign country without having being charged for a crime.
The US has deported Venezuelan to El Salvador. Some of them were legally living in the US.
One Salvadoran legally living in the US, and has a protected status preventing his deportation to El Salvador, was deported to El Salvador. He is in jail, not with his family. The US government won't bring him back.
That's why due process is important. You can't let government agents decide who gets deported and to which country. With the courts, the process is public and fallows a clearly defined process. With ICE, the process is secretive and arbitrary.
The government is not transparent about who is being deported. Some families discovered a family member had been deported because they saw them in a video filmed in an El Salvadorian prison.
How would Americans react if compatriots where deported to a foreign country without due process? My guess is, they would be outraged.
Login to reply
Replies (2)
Ive been engaging on this topic for some days, so this may be my last reply.
There are so many people in the US illegally, it would be basically impossible to give all of them due process and also have a court system. Even just 1,000,000 people (and its way more), at 1 hour per person of due pricess, is 1,000,000 hours.. Im not saying they shouldnt get it, but because there were administrations allowing an open border (illegally) this is a mess.
Entering the US illegally is a crime. No other ceime needs to be committed to be deported.
Venezuela will not accept their citizens back from the US, so they had to send them somewhere.
The "one salvadoran legally living in the US", it seems from what I am seeing the guy illegally entered the US, he had two legal deportation orders, and two courts found him to be tied to MS-13 and human trafficking. Also hes an El Salvadoran citizen, so he is back in his country of citizenship.
Americans would be outraged if they were deported to a foreign country, but they are not too worried about that, because they are legal citizens of the US. Trump made that comment about " home growns", and I am not a fan, but I also have no info to know exactly what that means.
I fully admit, its very difficult to get good info, or to even know what is true and what isnt. I also dont want any negativity for anyone, but i also understand why Americans dont like that so many people completely disrespect their immigration laws. I think the estimate is 13,000,000 people who went to the US illegally. Then many need assistance from the government (tax payers). Its a tough situation.
Abrego Garcia is a legal resident of the United States. His wife is an American citizen. He has no charges against him. He has a valid work permit. He is a sheet metal worker.
The federal judge presiding over his case said he has no criminal record in the US or El Salvador, and the gang ties is an unsubstantiated allegation.
In 2019, an immigration judge granted him legal protection from deportation on the grounds that he might be at risk of persecution from local gangs.
The court found his deportation illegal. The government acknowledged he was mistakenly deported to an El Salvador mega-prison.
The Supreme Court said that deportation requires due process and that the people sent El Salvador were not given due process.
"The Government's argument, moreover, implies that it could deport and incarcerate any person, including U. S. citizens, without legal consequence, so long as it does so before a court can intervene," wrote Justices Sonia Sotomayor, Elena Kagan and Ketanji Brown Jackson in a statement released with the Abrego Garcia ruling.
Trump asked Bukele to open 5 more facilities for homegrown criminals.
Personally, I don't think that extraordinary renditions going mainstream is good for democracy.