So many people casting rich men north of Richmond as right wing. I’m a punk rocker at heart and the first thing I thought when I heard it was wow, that’s pretty punk rock. And his statements since have borne that out. But you don’t have to look very far to find lyrics in songs many would consider left-wing in ethos that are totally analogous to parts or all of rich men north of Richmond. But that being said, it reminds me most of springsteen. And people forget how misunderstood “born in the USA” repeatedly is. The recurring line is not patriotism, it’s deeply felt angst of being treated unjustly and of having your life taken from you in a number of different ways, a lot of which is perpetrated by rich men, either north of Richmond or elsewhere. The protagonist is “born down in a dead man’s town” where the first kick he took is when he “hits the ground.” He describes ending up like “a dog that’s been beat too much” and spending half his life just to cover that feeling up. Sound familiar? He gets sent to Vietnam to get out of sole trouble. He’s told to kill for his country. He comes home to look for a job and is told nothing is available. He notes he had a brother over there with him who’s long gone, despite the enemy he was there to fight still remaining. The futility of the war. The song ends with one of Bruce’s most powerful closers: “Down in the shadow of the penitentiary Out by the gas fires of the refinery 10 years burning down the road Nowhere to run, ain’t got nowhere to go… Born in the USA.” I also thought of Bruce’s “the River,” which also works a similar vein of disenchantment, resignation, and angst, particularly with the state of the inflationary economy of 1980: “I got a job working construction for the Johnstown Company But lately there ain't been much work on account of the economy Now all them things that seemed so important, well mister they vanished right into the air Now I just act like I don't remember, Mary acts like she don't care..” It’s interesting to me how much things have changed that the left can now reflexively refer to rich men north of Richmond as right wing. But it’s also interesting how incorrect it is for GOP candidates to cosplay as springsteenian protagonists, too.

Replies (7)

Andy Flattery's avatar
Andy Flattery 2 years ago
Such a great point. Bruce is a much better artist than Anthony, but himself admits he’s always been playing a bit of a character in his songs. Anthony’s seeming authenticity really resonates on the internet. Would be interesting to look through Bruce’s catalog to see what all qualifies as “right wing” by today’s meaningless terms.
This is such a good point and an additional layer of interest. Because you’re right. Bruce had admitted to more or less cosplaying working class himself for ages. And these days his most ardent fans, from my empirical and unscientific observation, seem to be rich while liberal folks who enjoy the same cosplay. It’s all some kind of weird ritualistic absolution thing. Or at least has evolved from something true to that.
Default avatar
nobody 2 years ago
Very well said. What to me is so amazing is how rapidly this change has come. I think the flipping point was only 8 years ago during the Trump candidacy.
It's a great example of narrative control. Most fail to investigate the lyrics and reasoning for them due to an emotional reaction. Like any catchphrase or moto. The words no longer contain meaning and are placeholders for an ideological Rorschach Test. Something only certain outsiders like "old punks" most certainly understand.