How could an experiment be designed to measure the effectiveness (computer simulation )? That one way to think about it. Another way and I would say it's more kid like is to use your gut. For example, if we were playing a simulation game like Civilization and you had the option to allow guns like 2nd amendment or not like Europe what would you choose? I would choose to allow guns. Why? Because I have an exptation of my citizens to act morally and I also know my country is likely to be invaded (almost always happens). By trusting my citizens and arming them as the supreme omnipotent leader I would expect better security for my nation. Militias could be formed more quickly. It takes time to distribute guns and if the opposing general is serious that is precious time that can be exploited. In ending while I'm Christin I'll quote Lao tzu "By not trusting the people you make them untrustworthy"
Login to reply
Replies (2)
False dichotomy.
Europe allows guns and Europeans have some of the highest gun ownership rates per capita. Men in Bavaria are _more likely to own a gun_ than men in many areas of the US, and most men over 40 here have had military or police service.
Wikipedia says, "Countries that guarantee a right to keep and bear arms include Albania, Czech Republic, Guatemala, Mexico, Switzerland, the United States and Yemen." Switzerland and the Czech Republic don't have the problems the Americans do. They're some of the safest countries on the planet with miniscule homicide rates.
The Falkland Islands, Britain, has 62 guns per 100 people. That is more than one gun per adult male. There was been one gun murder there since 1980.
The 2nd Amendment results in Americans having a warped relationship with deadly weapons because they see them primarily as toys or political symbols. Americans own half of the world's civilian guns.
You actually don't need that many people owning guns to fight a professional army because armies are rather small, in comparison to the entire population. Germany has 1.4 million gun owners, in comparison to 182k active service members.
That's why the UK government nearly crapped their pants when a bunch of ethnic Brits marched downtown armed with FLAGPOLES.
Americans are just crazy but we like it that way. Now we have such a history and culture you can't take the guns away. We need to create better citizens. With Christ and Love it's possible.