Wow, what an amazing argument. To start with, I have 4 businesses across 3 states, 65 employees, and don't myself have W2 'income'. So I would love to know how would you propose I would do that? But let me get this straight. You are ok with the US government picking and choosing at random(or who has some votes more likely) groups of citizens they seem fit for not paying any taxes. Poor group A, but not B. C but not D? The tip culture is a drain and people hate it anyways. It encourages businesses in select industries to pay less for labor, and cash tips are always underreported. Talk about encouraging it income tax fraud. Wow. Jesus Christ that's asinine. Remove all income taxes, or make everyone pay. Period. The poor don't pay Jack as it is in income tax. It's already a bullshit system. Let's not advocate they make it worse. Nevermind the fact that the law probably won't pass nor likely pass the 14th amendment challenges that will come either.