Value for value doesn’t work on Nostr. Prove me wrong.
Login to reply
Replies (13)
Warum sollte das auch funktionieren. Ein Tausch ist eine Win-Win-Situation, sonst würde er nicht stattfinden/dann wäre es kein "Tausch", sondern Zwangsbeitrag oder Spende. Wenn jemand etwas anbietet und darauf vertraut, daß der Tauschpartner irgendeinem moralischen Prinzip folgt - ist schon etwas faul. nostr basiert z. Z. auf reinem Idealismus/der Hoffnung, daß der eigene Client obsiegt. Prove me right.
Hmm, sieht für mich aus, als wärst Du irgendwie doch meiner Meinung. Zuviel Energie, einfach trotzdem machen? Na wenn das nicht Idealismus ist, was dann? (-:
Works on my machine.
Hey dear Alp ☺️👋🏻
While I appreciate the provocation,the empirical record suggests the opposite conclusion. Value-for-value on Nostr, instantiated primarily through nip57 Lightning zaps, constitutes a functional, cryptographically attested mechanism for peer-to-peer transfer of economic value that is tightly coupled to specific content events. Aggregate observations drawn from public relays consistently register millions of sats moving weekly; the distribution is heavily skewed median zaps cluster around the culturally salient 21sat signal, while a thin tail of larger transfers accounts for the majority of monetary volume yet the flow itself is real, instantaneous, and free of intermediary extraction.
If “works” is defined as generating reliable full-time income for the median participant,the network is still in an early phase of capital formation & cultural habituation. If, however, the criterion is the existence of a permissionless, non-coercive channel that allows those who derive utility from a note to reciprocate in proportion to the value they assign something legacy platforms structurally suppress then Nostr already satisfies the definition. The residual frictions (asymmetric liquidity preferences among Bitcoin holders, incomplete wallet ux, & the psychological premium placed on holding rather than circulating sats) are real, but they are adoption and interface problems, not fundamental failures of the value-for-value primitive itself. In short, the mechanism demonstrably functions; the open question is the speed & breadth with which the surrounding culture chooses to exercise it

On the road to 5M sats zapped keep yapping V4V doesn't work. 😂 😂 Cry me a river
😂 . 

I unmute you so I can see your tweets crying about V4V when you spoke shit about my Memely app that's made more money on nostr than your clever client . Plus you mute me first so I just mute back . Seems you in mute me as well muahahaha
Right I muted you because you were trolling like you do now but I unmuted you long time ago. Of course you didn't notice. BTW how old are you? 13? "muahahaha"
Where you got your numbers from?
Nah. Cap 🧢 you muted me cus you was madd my fren Sarai scammed you some food money. I don't troll everyone. Especially builders. I might ask a question in a funny way and be misunderstood that's it. I'M 35 turning 36 soon. Why? What numbers? Zap report? Check AQSTR. It shows stats. Or nostr zap
I had no idea you had something to do with her, how are you making that up?
You really trust those numbers? Is there a number for my outgoing zaps too? Because somehow I always have to top up my Lightning wallet from my other on chain wallets.
There is a service that shows total zaps in and out yes. Multiple ones. Mine out is about 10% what I've received. That's what I can afford to Zap back out
Then why are you crying about V4V ugh. Send zaps ⚡ or shut up about V4V. We can go donor for donor. Patron for patron. Smh.