kinda.
bitcoin was crated to be p2p digital cash. it's right there on the whitepaper.
but, it turns out, it could never really be that without privacy.
on top of that we had the scaling issues too.
so we see what we see today: people and institutions hoard bitcoin but don't really use it much (not a criticism btw, I do the same because it's logical).
many are convinced it's the ngu aspect that makes people not want to spend. I'm sure that's a factor too, but speaking for myself it's 20% that and 80% the fact that I'm either doxxing my stash every time I transact, or I am employing inneficient countermeasures like coinjoins and then I'm passing the hot potato to the other guy, because now they own tainted bitcoin.
so, I do one thing and one thing only with my bitcoin. sell it for #monero on retoswap when I need to make larger purchases.
if bitcoin was properly private and anonymous, this would be a redundant step. but it isn't, so it isn't.
in the mean time the bitcoin served its purpose, went up in value (not always but usually).
Login to reply
Replies (3)
that is because they serve different purposes as i said
bitcoin became store of value; great for protection from inflation and for purchasing things that may require documents for protection (cars, homes, lands) and less privacy is what people search for this ones;
common misconception. you can buy all those things with monero too, you just need to be able to document how you have that wealth.
see: https://redlib.catsarch.com/r/Monero/comments/1qeabtn/guide_to_moving_large_amounts_of_monero_to_the/
as for the different purposes thing, that's what I meant by "kinda". bitcoin is only a sov and not really much of a moe because it turned out that without privacy no one in their right mind wants to use it.
it aimed to be both, but failed.
you should contest my opinion and not the facts. The market already did what i said.
If i were to say what bitcoin "can" be (and not what it is) i would be defending that it can be private and quote all layers and lightning and all that. Monero "can" be a great coin and be used to non-private stuff and even store of value, but it isn't what happened.
But if you really want to keep going this way for "all purposes", then why not zcash?