You're dishonestly putting words in my mouth: what I said above was defeating their military and crushing their economy. You don't need to kill everyone in Russia to accomplish that. That may of course happen in the long run due to a collapsed economy. But that's not our problem and we're not the ones responsible if it happens.
...and again, you show your disregard for actual victims: the 40 million Ukrainians who have to live under war. Bringing up the number of Russians is practically making an argument that we should go easy on them because there happens to be more of them.
It's kinda remarkable how close both situations are: in both cases you're protecting a violent, murderous, population that has repeatedly and intentionally massacred innocent people in their genocidal ambitions to wipe out a smaller minority group.
Login to reply
Replies (2)
Ok. Glad to hear that you don’t think all Russians need to be killed.
I don’t mean to show any disregard for Ukrainians. They are the victims. And I have appreciated how you stand up for them unlike the rest of the Bitcoin community. We just disagree on how best to help.
I would like us to protect innocent civilians. In my view that means a) Putin ending his war and retreating and b) an end to the IDF bombing and starving of Gaza and the end of Hamas
I understand that you think the only way to defeat Russian imperialism and Islamic terror is brute force violence, but I don’t agree. Can’t kill an idea. Far more long-term effective (not to mention more peaceful) if Russians or Palestinians can be mobilized to rise up and change their own governments. Germans run Germany peacefully today same with Japan, I see no reason why there can’t be a peaceful democratic Russia and Gaza in the future.
“Can't kill an idea”
What absurd nonsense. Ideas don't themselves kill people. Weapons kill people. Weapons that are paid for by economies.
The reason why Gaza is a threat to Israel – why Oct 7 happened – is because we allowed Gaza sovereignty and the ability to import huge amounts of supplies. Cutting off Gaza from the world solved that problem.
Killing Russia's economy also kills Russian imperialism. Whether or not the idea dies is irrelevant. If they can't afford weapons and soldiers, who cares?
Neither Nazism nor Japanese imperialism are dead ideas. But that's ok: we killed millions of the young people holding those ideas, and crushed the economies of the countries they lived in. Both ideas are mostly irrelevant because the people holding those ideas lost their economic power to use those ideas.
Extremist Islam isn't there yet. But we could get there pretty quickly by destroying the economy of just a few countries, mainly Iran. As I've said before, Israel should use their military power to destroy Iran now, while they still don't have nuclear weapons.
You would rather risk the lives of Ukrainians, and everyone else neighboring Russia, for the sake of Russians. You aren't even doing it well: you're HRF is literally platforming imperialists who seek to make Russia less corrupt, and thus better at fighting their next war. Imperialists who are also trying to get sanctions lifted on Russia, which would immediately help them win this war.
It's notable how HRF had four Russians on the recent program and only one Ukrainian, and then harassed the Ukrainian for pointing that out. They're fighting a clever diplomatic war, taking advantage of the fact that organizations like HRF are uncomfortable with military force – the actual solution to these problems. While you dither with words, Ukrainians die.
FWIW I'm very glad I didn't end up accepting funding from HRF for OpenTimestamps. I can't ethically work with you and would have had to cancel it.