I have been very often critical of Bukele, especially of the state spyware Chivo Wallet, and of the statist propaganda of many bitcoiners who portray El Salvador as "Bitcoin heaven." I must admit that it is good to read the president admit in his TIME interview that the adoption of Bitcoin in the country has NOT been the success that was expected. Truth always wins. TIME: I also want to ask you about the adoption of Bitcoin in El Salvador. (…) In your opinion, has it been a success? BUKELE: Yes and no; a lot more could definitely be done. Bitcoin hasn't had the widespread adoption we hoped for. (…) It hasn’t had the adoption we expected. The positive aspect is that it is voluntary; we have never forced anyone to adopt it. (…) For me, it is an option we have given to Salvadorans. I'm not going to say it's the currency of the future, but there's a lot of future in that currency. TIME: You bet a lot on Bitcoin. BUKELE: El Salvador invested $135 million. Now, we have $400 million in Bitcoin in the public wallet alone. (…) I feel that it could have worked better, and there is still time to make some improvements, but it hasn’t resulted in anything negative. On the contrary, it gave us branding, it brought us investments, it brought us tourism. (…) In the end, the fact of being a “First Mover,” I think, gives us a small advantage, as far as it goes. I feel that it could have been much better. I wouldn't consider it a resounding success. Still, I do believe that the positive outcomes outweigh the negative. Source: image

Replies (20)

It's been like 1 or 2 years? I dont like the time preference in Bukele's response. You gotta wait at least 8 years to make a call.
3 years now. He was asked the question now and RIGHTLY gave an opinion on the current situation.
iirc roughly 2% of El Salvadors 's polulation is in jail right now. That's an insane number. 🤯 In the interview he mentions that his concentrated action against the gangs imprisoned 1% of ES's population alone.
Thomas 's avatar
Thomas 1 year ago
„…it hasn’t resulted in anything negative. On the contrary, it gave us branding, it brought us investments, it brought us tourism.“ That are very valid and good developments. The problem was they just dumped Bitcoin into their society without a prior education campaign. As far as I understood it many people didn’t know what this whole thing is about. That is something many Bitcoiners are working on now.
I wish it was that simple. Keep in mind that they get paid in US dollars. But yes, education is crucial. But it’s gonna take time. A lot.
Sorry. My bad. Let me rephrase. Salvadorans earn dollars. Like it or not everyone in the emerging markets want the US dollar. Possibly cash. It is what it is. It’s undeniable. It’s the reason why they buy them on the black market for twice their value sometimes. It’s the reason there’s more USDT adoption that BTC adoption in the global south. I’m not saying I like it. It’s just the truth. Same in El Salvador. In order to boost adoption they need to understand that BTC is superior money compared to USD. And as you know it takes time. You need a profound comprehension of Bitcoin for that. It takes time.
Thomas 's avatar
Thomas 1 year ago
Ok got you. Yeah you have to distinguish between everyday USDT and Bitcoin which is still volatile and currently rather a longterm store of value. This will evolve maybe to one day being an everyday money as well.
Nah. Very expensive to make. Very long time frame for design and installation of facilities. Announced as it was it was mainly propaganda. Twenty years from now we will see.