There is a constant misunderstanding between open communities where the topic is not defined, like a "Reddit community" or a "BlueSky community", or a "Nostr community" and communities where the topic is defined. People join open communities to discuss whatever comes and join topic communities to stay on the topic and focus. Those are two different things. I don't see how topic communities can sustain their scope of discussion without moderation. And sustaining the scope is the whole point of establishing a community so that you can gather like-minded people.

Replies (3)

jb55's avatar
jb55 _@jb55.com 9 months ago
you can have moderated views of the community if you want, but that is up to the users choosing which moderated relays they want to use for that community.
historically, the cypherpunk mailing list was unmoderated and kept mostly on topic for more than a decade.
But that is just NIP-29, then: relay-based communities. We kinda had that for a while with NIP-28 public chats (we still have on Amethyst) where each relay has a different conversation going on while re-using the same community anchor id.