Melvin Carvalho's avatar
Melvin Carvalho
_@melvincarvalho.com
npub1melv...5c24
Mathematician and Web Developer
Melvin Carvalho's avatar
melvincarvalho 10 months ago
Hell threads are users attacking relay operators, who give up their time, to work for free. It's like going to a soup kitchen and throwing soup in the chef's face. Because they can. I understand tha aim is that the chefs, who work without pay, will improve their defenses. But a more likely outcome is that, when users throw soup in their face, they will just do other things with their free time.
Melvin Carvalho's avatar
melvincarvalho 10 months ago
One interesting thing about #pubky using a 12 word seed phrase instead of an nsec. It makes it obvious that your key also a wallet. #nostr keys are also bitcoin wallets, but I think most nostr users dont realize this immediately.
Melvin Carvalho's avatar
melvincarvalho 10 months ago
The strength of #pubky’s censorship resistance is that it doesn’t rely on DNS. With DNS, you can send a letter to a web server or relay and ask them to take something down — and history is full of examples where that’s exactly what happened. #Pubky works more like Bitcoin in that sense. To remove something from pubky, you’d basically need to take down the entire BitTorrent network. So far, it’s held its ground.
Melvin Carvalho's avatar
melvincarvalho 10 months ago
First impressions of #pubky vs #nostr mobile experience: pubkey is better than nostr desktop experience: nostr is better than pubky key management: nostr nsec is easier than 12 word seeds on boarding: pubky feels new and glitchy, but they are fixing things, nostr is more polished, glitches take longer to fix Still only day 1, but imho a great new addition to the open web. Cant wait to see how it evolves and for the public launch.
Melvin Carvalho's avatar
melvincarvalho 10 months ago
Testing #pubky app and it looks amazing so far. Both nostr and pubkey use the private key system (called nsec in nostr). So users can benefit from both apps. This will offer amazing new options, and full censorship resistance (ie 6 million nodes, vs 6 nodes) when it comes out of testing. Exciting possibilities for a truly-censorshp resistant new world!
Melvin Carvalho's avatar
melvincarvalho 10 months ago
In retrospect, the main value of did-nostr is its ability to unify Nostr and Bitcoin primitives within a single JSON object. This not only enables a 10x–100x architectural scaling potential for both systems, but also unlocks advanced use cases like on-chain zaps, trustless atomic swaps, decentralized contracts, consistent profiles and agentic Nostr. That said, I’m not entirely satisfied with the current DID spec—there are a couple of tweaks that would make a real difference. Still, it’s a significant improvement over what we have today, and those edge cases can be fixed later. 🔗 image
Melvin Carvalho's avatar
melvincarvalho 10 months ago
We are pleased to announce the publication of the First Public Working Draft for the did:nostr method specification: This specification defines a Decentralized Identifier (DID) method (did:nostr) that utilizes the cryptographic key pairs inherent to the Nostr protocol. It describes how a did:nostr identifier can be created, resolved to a DID Document. This initial draft represents the collaborative effort of several contributors. We would like to extend our sincere thanks to: - Maximillian George for valuable feedback and support throughout the initial stages. - Manu Sporny for providing an essential sanity check on the approach and structure. - The team at Block for engaging in insightful discussions that helped shape the work. We believe the specification is now at a stage where it is ready for broader review and contributions. We warmly welcome feedback, suggestions, issue reporting, and contributions from the CG and W3C DID community and anyone interested in integrating Nostr identities with did-identity standards. We look forward to engaging with the community to refine and advance this specification.